Infisical vs. BeyondTrust Secrets Safe
BeyondTrust Secrets Safe is the secrets store inside its Password Safe PAM suite. Infisical is built for application secrets: open source, self-hostable on containers, with per-secret access, rotation, dynamic secrets, and workloads that sign in with their platform identity.
What's the difference between Infisical and BeyondTrust Secrets Safe?
Both store application secrets and serve them through an API and a CLI. BeyondTrust started with privileged access for human administrators and added a secrets store later. Infisical was built for application secrets from the start.
Where features live
BeyondTrust's rotation and approvals belong to Password Safe and cover managed accounts, not secrets in Secrets Safe. Dynamic secrets live in Workload Credentials, a separate cloud-only beta. Infisical offers all three for the secrets you store.
Workload access
Apps reach Secrets Safe with a stored API key or OAuth secret, so every workload needs one long-lived credential to fetch the rest. Infisical workloads use the identity their platform issues, such as a Kubernetes service account or AWS IAM role.
Deployment
Self-hosted BeyondTrust runs on Windows Server, IIS and full SQL Server, or as a Windows-based appliance. Infisical runs as stateless containers on PostgreSQL and Redis, and a license unlocks the same features as Infisical Cloud.
What's similar
Both keep version history, export audit logs to a SIEM, and offer a managed cloud with a SOC 2 Type II report. For simply storing and retrieving secrets, both do the job.
Infisical vs. BeyondTrust Secrets Safe at a glance
Secrets Safe handles storage and retrieval. The gaps are in how a secret is scoped, rotated, delivered and governed, and what it takes to run.
| Feature |  | BeyondTrust Secrets Safe |
|---|---|---|
| Platform and deployment | ||
| Open source | Yes. MIT-licensed core, developed on GitHub | No. Closed source. Only clients and integrations are public |
| Self-hosting | Yes. Every plan, including free | Partial. Yes, but Workload Credentials is cloud-only |
| Self-hosted infrastructure | Stateless containers on PostgreSQL and Redis | Windows Server, IIS and SQL Server, or a Windows appliance |
| Managed cloud | Yes. US and EU regions, or a dedicated instance | Yes. Single-tenant on Azure |
| Product scope | Secrets, certificates (PKI), privileged access, KMS | Secrets, within the Password Safe PAM suite |
| Secrets management | ||
| Secret structure | Projects, environments, folders, imports and references | Safes and folders, no environments |
| Secret rotation | Yes. 28+ types, Advanced plan and above | Partial. Password Safe managed accounts only |
| Dynamic secrets | Yes. 30+ templates, Advanced plan and above | Partial. AWS and Azure, in a cloud-only beta |
| Syncs and integrations | Yes. 49+ secret sync destinations | Partial. No push syncs, pull integrations only |
| Kubernetes | Yes. Operator, CSI provider and injector, native auth | Partial. ESO provider and agent, with stored credentials |
| Access and governance | ||
| Access control | Yes. RBAC and ABAC down to one secret, temporary access | Partial. Set per safe, not per secret |
| Platform-native workload identity | Yes. 13+ methods, including Kubernetes, cloud IAM, OIDC and SPIFFE | No. Static API keys or OAuth secrets |
| SAML SSO | Yes. Pro plan and above | Yes |
| SCIM | Yes. Enterprise plan | Yes |
| Approval workflows | Yes. Enterprise plan | Partial. Password Safe managed accounts only |
| Audit log retention | 30 days (Pro), 90 days (Advanced), custom (Enterprise) | 120 days, fixed on Cloud |
| Pricing | ||
| Pricing model | Published per-identity prices, free trials | Quote only, through sales |
| Free tier | Up to 5 identities | None |
Frequently asked questions
Everything you need to know. Can't find an answer? Talk to our team.
Which one is right for you?
Both store and serve application secrets. The better fit depends on what you already run, and whether application secrets or privileged human access is the bigger problem.
Choose Infisical if
- Your main problem is application and machine credentials, not privileged human access.
- You need rotation and dynamic secrets for stored secrets, generally available today.
- Your workloads should authenticate with Kubernetes, cloud IAM or OIDC, not an API key.
- You want to self-host on containers, not Windows Server and SQL Server.
- You want published pricing and a free tier.
Choose BeyondTrust Secrets Safe if
- You already run Password Safe and want secrets in the same console.
- Your compliance reporting is built on BeyondInsight.
- Your team already operates Windows Server and SQL Server.
- You need a managed cloud region outside the US and EU.
How to migrate from BeyondTrust Secrets Safe to Infisical
There is no one-click import, but Secrets Safe's API and CLI read secrets out, so most teams move one safe at a time.
- 01
Map safes to projects
List the safes that hold application secrets and the apps that read them. Safes split by environment usually become one project with dev, staging and prod.
- 02
Move the values
Export secrets with the Secrets Safe API or CLI, then import them with the Infisical CLI, the API or a .env file.
- 03
Switch workload authentication
Replace API keys and OAuth secrets with machine identities, and swap the Secrets Safe agent for the Infisical operator. External Secrets Operator users switch to its Infisical provider.
- 04
Cut over and revoke
Move one app at a time. Once nothing reads from a safe, revoke its API registration and retire it.